The Tombstone Daily Nugget was a significant newspaper published in Tombstone, Arizona, during the early 1880s, a period marked by the town’s rapid growth as a silver mining boomtown. Operating from 1880 to 1882, the newspaper served as a primary source of news and opinion, reflecting the political, social, and economic dynamics of a frontier community. This report explores the origins, operations, editorial stance, and historical impact of the Tombstone Daily Nugget, drawing on available historical records.
Origins and Establishment
The Tombstone Daily Nugget began publication in 1880 in Tombstone, Cochise County, Arizona Territory, during the height of the town’s silver mining boom, sparked by Ed Schieffelin’s 1877 discovery. Published by A.E. Fay & Co., and later by H.M. Woods & Co., the newspaper was a daily (except Mondays) and positioned itself as the “leading and representative mining paper of Arizona.” Its first known issue is documented as Volume 1, Number 228, dated June 8, 1881, though it began in 1880. The Daily Nugget emerged alongside its weekly counterpart, The Weekly Nugget (1879–188?), and was closely related to The Daily Nugget (1880–18??), published in Pima County.
Tombstone’s rapid growth, fueled by mining wealth, created a demand for local news. The Daily Nugget filled this need, covering mining developments, local politics, and social events. Its establishment coincided with the founding of its rival, The Tombstone Epitaph, by John P. Clum in May 1880, setting the stage for a fierce editorial rivalry that mirrored the town’s political divisions.
Operations and Content
The Tombstone Daily Nugget was a four-page broadsheet, typically measuring 17 x 22.5 inches, as evidenced by a surviving issue from April 7, 1882. It was printed daily, except Mondays, and focused heavily on mining news, given Tombstone’s economic reliance on silver. The newspaper also covered local and national events, legal proceedings, and social happenings, such as births, deaths, and community gatherings. Its content included advertisements, editorials, and occasional humorous or satirical pieces, reflecting the vibrant and often contentious atmosphere of the town.
A notable issue from April 7, 1882, featured articles on the assassination of outlaw Jesse James by the Ford brothers and a humorous report on Wyatt Earp’s arrest of a Texas desperado, highlighting the paper’s blend of serious and lighthearted content. The Daily Nugget also published accounts of local conflicts, such as the coroner’s inquest following the 1881 Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, providing detailed witness testimonies.
The newspaper’s operations were likely modest, typical of frontier journalism, with limited staff and reliance on hand-set type and flatbed presses. While specific details about its circulation are unavailable, its role as a daily suggests it was widely read among Tombstone’s residents, including miners, merchants, and civic leaders.
Editorial Stance and Rivalry
The Tombstone Daily Nugget was a Democratic-leaning publication, in stark contrast to the Republican-leaning Tombstone Epitaph. This political alignment shaped its editorial perspective, particularly in its coverage of local law enforcement and the tensions between the Earp brothers and the Cochise County Cowboys. The Epitaph, under John Clum, supported the Earps and local Republicans, while the Nugget often aligned with ranchers, Democrats, and the Cowboys, who were frequently at odds with the town’s mining interests and law enforcement.
This rivalry was not merely ideological but deeply personal, with the two newspapers engaging in “editorial fencing” that amplified Tombstone’s political divisions. The Nugget’s coverage of the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral on October 26, 1881, for instance, differed from the Epitaph’s, reflecting its sympathy for the Cowboys and skepticism of the Earps’ actions. The Nugget published detailed accounts of the coroner’s inquest, including witness statements that questioned the Earps’ conduct, such as B.H. Fellehy’s testimony about the rapid sequence of shots.
Key Historical Context
The Tombstone Daily Nugget operated during a pivotal moment in Tombstone’s history, when the town was a flashpoint for frontier tensions. The silver boom attracted a diverse population, including miners, gamblers, and outlaws, leading to conflicts over law, order, and economic control. The Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, involving Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and the Clanton and McLaury brothers, was a defining event, and the Nugget’s coverage provided a counterpoint to the Epitaph’s pro-Earp narrative.
The newspaper also documented other incidents, such as John Ringo’s 1881 shooting of Louis Hancock over a dispute about drinks, illustrating the town’s volatile social environment. Beyond local events, the Nugget connected Tombstone to broader national stories, as seen in its reporting on Jesse James’ death in 1882.
Decline and Legacy
The Tombstone Daily Nugget ceased publication in 1882, likely due to a combination of factors. A devastating fire in May 1882 destroyed much of Tombstone’s business district, including the Nugget’s offices, a blow from which it did not recover. Additionally, the decline of the silver boom and the town’s population reduced the demand for a daily newspaper. The Tombstone Epitaph, which survived the fire, outlasted its rival and continues as Arizona’s oldest continuously published newspaper.
No complete digital archive of the Tombstone Daily Nugget exists online, and surviving issues are rare, often available only on microfilm through institutions like the Arizona Newspaper Project. However, its articles, such as those preserved in auction records and historical accounts, offer valuable insights into Tombstone’s frontier life. The Nugget’s Democratic perspective provides a critical counterbalance to the Epitaph’s Republican narrative, enriching the historical record of events like the O.K. Corral gunfight.
Conclusion
The Tombstone Daily Nugget was a vital voice in Tombstone, Arizona, during its brief but impactful run from 1880 to 1882. As a Democratic-leaning newspaper, it chronicled the town’s mining boom, political rivalries, and violent conflicts, often in opposition to its rival, The Tombstone Epitaph. Despite its destruction in the 1882 fire and subsequent closure, the Nugget left a lasting legacy through its documentation of a transformative period in the American West. Its surviving issues, though scarce, remain a treasure for historians and genealogists seeking to understand the complexities of frontier life in Tombstone.
Sources
- Chronicling America, Library of Congress.
- Newspaper Abstracts.
- Legends of America.
- Bidsquare Auction Records.
- Tombstone Chamber of Commerce.