Big Bear, CA
I quiet mountain community full of back country adventure.
John Augustus Sutter
In 1847, John Augustus Sutter partnered with James Marshall to construct a sawmill, where Marshall’s 1848 gold discovery sparked the California Gold Rush.
Early Life
John Augustus Sutter was born Johann August Sutter on February 23, 1803, in Kandern, Baden (then part of the Grand Duchy of Baden, near France). Raised in a family of modest means, Sutter apprenticed as a merchant and briefly served in the Swiss military. In 1834, facing financial difficulties and debts, he left his wife and five children in Switzerland and emigrated to the United States, seeking new opportunities. His ambition and charisma would define his ventures in the American West.
Journey to California
Sutter arrived in New York in 1834 and spent several years traveling across the United States, engaging in trade and commerce in Missouri and New Mexico. In 1838, he set out for California, then under Mexican control, via a circuitous route through Oregon, Hawaii, and Alaska. Arriving in Monterey in 1839, Sutter persuaded Mexican authorities to grant him nearly 50,000 acres in the Sacramento Valley. He established a settlement called New Helvetia (New Switzerland), centered around Sutter’s Fort, which became a hub for trade, agriculture, and immigration.
Sutter’s Fort and Ambitions
Sutter envisioned New Helvetia as a self-sufficient agricultural empire. He employed Native Americans and European settlers, cultivating crops, raising livestock, and building infrastructure. His fort served as a trading post and a waypoint for American pioneers crossing the Sierra Nevada. Sutter’s entrepreneurial spirit made him a prominent figure in Mexican California, and he gained Mexican citizenship to secure his land grant. By the mid-1840s, he was a leading landowner and employer in the region, with plans to expand his operations through ventures like a sawmill on the American River.
The Gold Rush and Downfall
In 1847, Sutter partnered with James Marshall to construct a sawmill in Coloma, California. On January 24, 1848, Marshall discovered gold at the site, a find that would ignite the California Gold Rush. While the discovery brought global attention to California, it proved disastrous for Sutter. Thousands of prospectors, known as “Forty-Niners,” flooded his land, trampling crops, slaughtering livestock, and squatting on his property. Sutter’s attempts to control the influx or profit from the gold failed, as his workers abandoned their posts to join the rush. The sawmill project collapsed, and his finances deteriorated.
Sutter sought legal recourse to protect his land claims, but the transition of California to American control after the Mexican-American War (1846–1848) complicated his efforts. Courts often ruled against him, and by the 1850s, he was bankrupt. His dreams of a prosperous empire unraveled as he lost much of his land and wealth.
Later Life and Legacy
In the 1860s, Sutter moved to Lititz, Pennsylvania, where he lived modestly with his family, supported by a small pension from the California legislature. He spent his final years petitioning the U.S. government for compensation for his lost lands, but his appeals were largely unsuccessful. Sutter died on June 18, 1880, in Washington, D.C., while pursuing his claims.
John Sutter’s life reflects the highs and lows of the California frontier. His establishment of Sutter’s Fort facilitated American expansion, and his land became the epicenter of the Gold Rush, which transformed California into an economic powerhouse. Yet, the very event that cemented his historical significance led to his personal ruin. Sutter’s legacy endures as a symbol of ambition, opportunity, and the unpredictable consequences of the Gold Rush era.
James Wilson Marshall
James Wilson Marshall (October 8, 1810 – August 10, 1885) was an American carpenter and millwright whose discovery of gold on January 24, 1848, at Sutter’s Mill in Coloma, California, sparked the California Gold Rush
Early Life
James Wilson Marshall was born on October 8, 1810, in Hopewell Township, New Jersey. Raised on a farm, he developed practical skills in carpentry and mechanics, which would later define his contributions to history. In his early twenties, Marshall left home, seeking opportunity in the American West. He worked as a carpenter and farmer in states like Ohio, Illinois, and Missouri before heading further west to California in 1844, drawn by the promise of new lands and possibilities.
Arrival in California
Marshall arrived in California during the Mexican-American War, settling in the Sacramento Valley. He found work at Sutter’s Fort, owned by Swiss immigrant John Sutter, a prominent entrepreneur and landowner. Marshall’s skills as a carpenter and millwright made him invaluable, and he soon became Sutter’s trusted partner in various ventures. In 1847, Sutter tasked Marshall with constructing a sawmill along the American River in Coloma, California, to supply lumber for the growing settlement.
The Discovery of Gold
On January 24, 1848, while inspecting the mill’s tailrace, Marshall noticed something extraordinary: small, shiny flecks in the riverbed. He collected the particles and, after rudimentary tests, confirmed they were gold. This discovery at Sutter’s Mill sparked the California Gold Rush, one of the most transformative events in American history. Marshall and Sutter initially tried to keep the find secret, fearing it would disrupt their operations, but word spread rapidly. By 1849, thousands of “Forty-Niners” flooded California, drawn by the promise of wealth.
Impact and Challenges
While Marshall’s discovery reshaped California and the nation, he personally reaped little reward. The influx of prospectors overwhelmed Sutter’s land, destroying crops and livestock, and the sawmill project collapsed. Marshall struggled to assert mining claims and faced hostility from fortune-seekers who encroached on his land. Legal battles and financial difficulties followed, and he never achieved the wealth his discovery promised. Instead, he turned to farming and later operated a vineyard in Coloma, but these ventures met with limited success.
Later Life and Legacy
In his later years, Marshall lived modestly, supported occasionally by small pensions from the state of California, which recognized his role in the Gold Rush. He died on August 10, 1885, in Kelsey, California, largely forgotten by the public. Despite his lack of personal gain, Marshall’s discovery catalyzed California’s rapid growth, transforming it into a global economic hub and accelerating American westward expansion.
James Marshall’s life embodies the paradox of the Gold Rush: a moment of historic fortune that brought prosperity to many but left its discoverer in obscurity. His legacy endures in the story of California’s transformation and the enduring allure of the American Dream.
The California Gold Rush
The California Gold Rush (1848–1855) was a transformative event in American history, sparking a massive migration of people to California in pursuit of wealth and reshaping the state’s social, economic, and environmental landscape. Triggered by the discovery of gold at Sutter’s Mill in January 1848, the rush drew an estimated 300,000 people from across the United States and the world, turning a sparsely populated territory into a bustling hub of commerce and culture. This report provides a comprehensive examination of the Gold Rush, covering its origins, key developments, societal impacts, and lasting legacy, drawing on primary accounts and historical records.
Origins: The Discovery at Sutter’s Mill
On January 24, 1848, James W. Marshall, a carpenter working for Swiss entrepreneur Johann (John) Sutter, discovered gold flakes in the tailrace of a sawmill on the American River in Coloma, California. Marshall’s find occurred at Sutter’s Mill, part of Sutter’s ambitious agricultural and commercial empire in the Mexican territory of Alta California. Sutter, wary of the disruption gold would cause, attempted to keep the discovery secret, but his efforts failed. Samuel Brannan, a San Francisco merchant, publicized the find in spring 1848, famously running through the streets with a vial of gold, shouting, “Gold! Gold from the American River!” By May 1848, San Francisco’s Californian newspaper reported the discovery, igniting local excitement.
News spread slowly at first, but by August 1848, the New York Herald published reports of the gold find, and President James K. Polk confirmed the discovery in his December 1848 address to Congress, citing “an abundance of gold” in California. This official endorsement triggered a global frenzy, as prospectors, known as “Forty-Niners,” began flocking to California.
The Rush Begins: Migration and the Forty-Niners
The Gold Rush attracted an estimated 300,000 people to California between 1848 and 1855, transforming its population from about 14,000 (excluding Native Americans) in 1848 to over 300,000 by 1854. Migrants came from diverse regions:
- Overland Routes: Approximately 150,000 Americans traveled overland via trails like the California Trail, a 2,000-mile journey from Missouri River towns. The journey, often taking 4–6 months, was perilous, with dangers including disease (cholera killed thousands), harsh weather, and conflicts with Native Americans. The Donner Party’s tragic 1846–1847 ordeal underscored the risks.
- Sea Routes: Others sailed from eastern U.S. ports, either around Cape Horn (a 15,000-mile, 5–8-month voyage) or via Panama, where steamships and a treacherous jungle crossing shortened the trip to 2–3 months. By 1849, 42,000 arrived overland, and 39,000 came by sea.
- International Migrants: The rush drew people from Mexico (25,000), China (20,000 by 1852), South America (notably Chile and Peru), Europe (especially Ireland and Germany), and Australia. Chinese miners, facing discrimination, often worked abandoned claims, contributing significantly to mining communities.
San Francisco, a small settlement of 1,000 in 1848, grew to 25,000 by 1850, becoming a chaotic boomtown with inflated prices (a dozen eggs cost $10 in 1849, equivalent to $400 today).
Mining Techniques and Economic Impact
Early Mining: Placer Gold
In 1848–1849, most gold was extracted through placer mining, a simple method using pans, rockers, and sluices to wash gold from streambeds. Miners worked rivers like the American, Feather, and Yuba, often earning $20–$50 daily (equivalent to $800–$2,000 today). By 1849, California produced $10 million in gold (about $400 million today).
Technological Advancements
As surface gold dwindled, miners adopted more advanced techniques:
- Long Toms and Sluices: By 1850, long toms (extended sluices) processed larger volumes of gravel, increasing efficiency.
- Hydraulic Mining: Introduced in 1853, hydraulic mining used high-pressure water jets to blast hillsides, extracting gold from deeper deposits. This method, pioneered by Edward Matteson, produced massive yields but caused severe environmental damage, silting rivers and flooding farmland.
- Hard-Rock Mining: By 1855, miners turned to quartz veins, requiring costly equipment like stamp mills to crush ore. The Empire Mine in Grass Valley, operational until 1956, became one of California’s most productive hard-rock mines.
Gold production peaked in 1853 at $81 million, declining to $45 million by 1857 as easily accessible deposits were exhausted. California’s total gold output from 1848–1855 was approximately $400 million (over $16 billion today).
Societal and Cultural Impacts
Demographic Transformation
The Gold Rush created a diverse, male-dominated society. In 1850, only 8% of California’s population was female, leading to a rough, transient culture. Mining camps like Hangtown (Placerville) and Rough and Ready were marked by gambling, saloons, and violence. Racial tensions were rampant:
- Native Americans: The Native population plummeted from 150,000 in 1845 to 30,000 by 1860 due to disease, starvation, and violence. The 1850 Act for the Government and Protection of Indians facilitated forced labor and land theft.
- Chinese Miners: Facing the 1850 Foreign Miners Tax ($20/month, repealed in 1851 but reimposed in 1852), Chinese miners were often relegated to marginal claims. Anti-Chinese violence and exclusion laws persisted into the 1880s.
- Latin American Miners: Mexicans and Chileans faced similar discrimination, with many driven from claims by mobs.
Economic and Political Development
The Gold Rush spurred California’s rapid statehood. In 1849, a constitutional convention in Monterey drafted a state constitution, and California was admitted as a free state on September 9, 1850, bypassing territorial status. The influx of gold bolstered the U.S. economy, stabilizing the national currency and funding infrastructure like the First Transcontinental Railroad (completed 1869).
San Francisco became a financial hub, with banks like Wells Fargo (founded 1852) emerging to handle gold shipments. Agriculture and commerce flourished to supply mining camps, with Sacramento and Stockton growing as supply centers.
Environmental Devastation
Mining techniques, especially hydraulic mining, caused widespread environmental destruction. By 1884, hydraulic mining had washed away entire hillsides, dumping 1.5 billion cubic yards of debris into rivers like the Sacramento and San Joaquin. This siltation ruined farmland and caused flooding, leading to the 1884 Sawyer Decision, which banned hydraulic mining without debris containment. Deforestation and mercury pollution (used in gold amalgamation) further scarred the landscape, with effects lingering today.
Key Figures and Stories
- John Sutter: Once a wealthy landowner, Sutter was ruined by the Gold Rush as squatters overran his land and workers abandoned his enterprises. He died bankrupt in 1880.
- James Marshall: The discoverer of gold, Marshall failed to profit from his find and died impoverished in 1885.
- Samuel Brannan: California’s first millionaire, Brannan amassed wealth through his store and real estate but lost his fortune to alcoholism and poor investments by the 1880s.
- Levi Strauss: Arriving in 1853, Strauss supplied durable denim pants to miners, laying the foundation for Levi’s jeans.
- Lola Montez: A dancer and actress, Montez became a Gold Rush celebrity, performing in mining camps and settling in Grass Valley.
The Decline of the Gold Rush
By 1855, the Gold Rush waned as surface gold became scarce and mining required capital-intensive methods beyond the reach of individual prospectors. Many Forty-Niners left California, some returning home, others joining rushes in Australia (1851) or Colorado (1859). Mining corporations dominated, employing wage laborers in large-scale operations. The population stabilized, and California transitioned to an agricultural and industrial economy.
Legacy
The California Gold Rush left an indelible mark on American history:
- Population and Diversity: It transformed California into a global crossroads, with lasting cultural diversity from Chinese, Mexican, and European communities.
- Economic Growth: Gold fueled national expansion, while infrastructure like railroads and ports strengthened California’s economy.
- Indigenous Dispossession: The rush accelerated Native American displacement, setting a precedent for later U.S. policies.
- Environmental Impact: The ecological damage from mining prompted early conservation efforts, influencing modern environmental laws.
- Cultural Mythology: The Gold Rush birthed enduring legends, from the Lost Cement Mine to tales of instant wealth, shaping America’s frontier ethos.
Today, sites like Marshall Gold Discovery State Historic Park in Coloma and the California State Mining and Mineral Museum in Mariposa preserve the Gold Rush’s history. The rush remains a symbol of ambition, opportunity, and the complex costs of rapid change.
Notable People of the California Gold Rush
 James Wilson MarshallJames Marshall James Wilson Marshall (October 8, 1810 – August 10, 1885) was an American carpenter and millwright whose discovery of gold on January 24,… |
 John Augustus SutterIn 1847, John Augustus Sutter partnered with James Marshall to construct a sawmill, where Marshall’s 1848 gold discovery sparked the California Gold Rush. Early Life… |
Bibliography
- Brands, H.W. The Age of Gold: The California Gold Rush and the New American Dream. Anchor Books, 2003.
- Holliday, J.S. The World Rushed In: The California Gold Rush Experience. Simon & Schuster, 1981.
- Rawls, James J., and Orsi, Richard J. A Golden State: Mining and Economic Development in Gold Rush California. University of California Press, 1999.
- “California Gold Rush.” National Park Service, www.nps.gov.
- “The California Gold Rush.” PBS American Experience, www.pbs.org.
- “Gold Rush Overview.” California State Library, www.library.ca.gov.
- Starr, Kevin. California: A History. Modern Library, 2005.
The Lost Cement Mine
The Lost Cement Mine is one of California’s most enduring legends from the Gold Rush era, a tale of fabulous wealth hidden in the rugged terrain of the eastern Sierra Nevada. First discovered in 1857, this elusive gold vein has captivated prospectors, adventurers, and historians for over a century. Described as a ledge of rusty, reddish “cement” laced with pure gold, the mine’s story is steeped in mystery, misfortune, and the allure of untold riches. This report explores the historical context, discovery, subsequent searches, and enduring legacy of the Lost Cement Mine, drawing on primary accounts and historical records to separate fact from folklore.
Historical Context: The California Gold Rush
The discovery of gold at Sutter’s Mill in 1848 sparked the California Gold Rush, drawing over 80,000 prospectors to the region by 1849 alone. Miners scoured the Sierra Nevada and other areas, extracting millions in gold through placer mining and, later, hard-rock mining. By 1853, gold yields peaked at over $81 million, but the rush also left behind thousands of abandoned claims and tales of “lost mines” when prospectors died, fell ill, or lost their way. The Lost Cement Mine emerged in this frenzied era, its legend fueled by the promise of easy wealth in a landscape where gold seemed to lie just beneath the surface.
The Discovery of the Lost Cement Mine
In 1857, two German prospectors traveling with a California-bound wagon train reportedly separated from their group near the headwaters of the Owens River in the eastern Sierra Nevada. While resting near a stream in what one described as “the burnt country,” they stumbled upon a peculiar ledge of red lava rock studded with lumps of gold, resembling cement in the miners’ parlance of the time. One prospector, skeptical of the find, laughed as his companion collected about ten pounds of ore and drew a crude map of the location. Misfortune struck during their journey: one broke his leg and was left to die, while the survivor, weakened by exhaustion, reached the mining camp of Millerton. There, suffering from tuberculosis, he sought treatment from Dr. Randall, paying him with the ore and the map before succumbing to his illness.
Dr. Randall and the Search for the Mine
Dr. Randall, intrigued by the gold-laden ore, shared the story with friends and organized a prospecting expedition in 1861 to Pumice Flat, approximately eight miles north of Mammoth Canyon near Mono Lake. Accompanied by his assistant Gid Whiteman and other miners, Randall’s party reportedly extracted several thousand dollars’ worth of gold from a ledge, believed to be the Lost Cement Mine. However, the Owens Valley Indian War (1861–1867) disrupted their efforts, as tensions with the Paiute people escalated due to the influx of prospectors. The two German discoverers were allegedly killed by Native Americans, and the mine’s precise location was lost. Word of the find spread, sparking a frenzy among miners in nearby camps like Monoville and Mammoth City.
James W.A. Wright’s Account and Speculation
In 1879, James W.A. Wright, a former Confederate officer and Princeton graduate, published a series of articles in the San Francisco Daily Evening Post detailing his travels through Mono County’s mining camps. Wright speculated that the Lost Cement Mine might have been located across the Sierra Crest, near Devils Postpile, and suggested it had been secretly mined for years before the site was concealed by destroying a mining cabin. His detailed descriptions of the terrain between Monoville and Mammoth City, combined with hearsay from local prospectors, added credibility to the legend. Wright’s work, later compiled into the book The Lost Cement Mine by Richard Lingenfelter, remains a key source, blending firsthand observation with speculative lore.
Mark Twain and the Cultural Impact
The allure of the Lost Cement Mine even drew the attention of Mark Twain, who recounted his own midnight expedition to find it in his 1872 book Roughing It. Accompanied by sketches from the first edition, Twain’s humorous account of his fruitless search underscores the mine’s grip on the public imagination. The legend inspired countless prospectors, with stories of gold “as thick as raisins in a fruit cake” fueling searches well into the 20th century. A historical marker erected in 1980 by the Bodie Chapter of E Clampus Vitus near Owens River Road in Crestview commemorates the mine, noting its discovery in 1857 and periodic rediscoveries until 1877, though its location remains a secret.
Geological and Historical Plausibility
The Lost Cement Mine’s description as a gold-laden ledge of red igneous rock raises geological questions. Most gold deposits in the Sierra Nevada occur in quartz veins or placer deposits, not in cement-like matrices. However, as noted in historical accounts, gold can appear in unexpected forms, and similar “cement-like” gold deposits have been documented elsewhere, such as the Lost White Cement Mine in Colorado and the Lost Mine of Manly Peak in Death Valley. The eastern Sierra’s volcanic history, particularly around Mammoth Lakes, supports the possibility of igneous rock hosting gold, though no definitive evidence confirms the mine’s existence. The region’s mining camps, including Dogtown, Mammoth City, and Bodie, thrived on real gold discoveries, suggesting the legend may have a factual basis.
Legacy and Modern Interest
The Lost Cement Mine remains a potent symbol of the Gold Rush’s promise and peril. Its story has been perpetuated through books, historical markers, and personal accounts, such as a 1950s recollection of a prospector’s father finding a cement-like creek bed near Mono Lake. Today, the mine is part of California’s rich tapestry of lost treasure legends, alongside others like the Lost Pegleg Mine. While modern prospectors occasionally search the Ritter Range or the San Joaquin River’s headwaters, the mine’s elusiveness endures, partly due to the region’s dense forests and rugged terrain. The Bureau of Land Management notes that California hosts approximately 47,000 abandoned mine sites, many posing safety hazards, underscoring the challenges of exploring such areas.
Conclusion
The Lost Cement Mine encapsulates the hope, hardship, and mystery of California’s Gold Rush era. From its 1857 discovery by two ill-fated German prospectors to its tantalizing rediscoveries and ultimate concealment, the mine’s legend has endured through accounts like those of Dr. Randall, James W.A. Wright, and Mark Twain. While its geological plausibility remains debated, the mine’s cultural and historical significance is undeniable, inspiring generations to chase dreams of hidden gold in the Sierra Nevada. As a historical marker near Mammoth Lakes wryly suggests, if you stumble upon a ledge of gold, the E Clampus Vitus would appreciate a call to relocate their monument—perhaps the closest we’ll come to finding the Lost Cement Mine.
Bibliography
- Wright, James W.A. The Lost Cement Mine. Edited by Richard Lingenfelter, 1984.
- “Lost Cement Mine.” Wikipedia, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Cement_Mine.
- Weiser-Alexander, Kathy. “Lost Cement Gold Mine of Mammoth Mountain, California.” Legends of America, www.legendsofamerica.com.
- “Lost Cement Mine Historical Marker.” Historical Marker Database, www.hmdb.org.
- “The Legend of the Lost Cement Mine.” Amusing Planet, www.amusingplanet.com.
- “Abandoned Mines in California.” U.S. Department of the Interior, www.doi.gov.
Arizona Republic – June 26, 1931
The disappearance of Adolph Ruth in the Superstition Mountains as reported by the Arizona Republic on June 26, 1931.
Adolph Ruth was a 66-year-old veterinarian and amateur treasure hunter from Washington, D.C., who became a central figure in the legend of the Lost Dutchman’s Gold Mine due to his mysterious disappearance and death in Arizona’s Superstition Mountains in 1931. Born in 1866, Ruth developed a passion for treasure hunting, inspired by tales of lost mines in the American West. His interest intensified after his son, Erwin Ruth, a veterinarian working in Mexico during the Mexican Revolution, acquired maps in 1912 from Pedro Gonzalez, who claimed descent from the Peralta family, allegedly linked to the fabled mine. These maps purportedly led to abandoned Spanish mines, one of which Ruth believed was the Lost Dutchman’s Mine.
Superstition Range Is Believed To Have Claimed New Victim
FROM 3,000 miles across the nation, the famous legend of the Lost Dutchman mine lured a 70 year old prospector into the Superstition mountains, 35 miles east of Phoenix 13 day ago – and yesterday it was feared, he had perished.
Ranchers and homesteaders in the vicinity of the mountains appealed to officers at Florence for aid yesterday after several days of intensive but unsuccessful search for A. Ruth, 70 years old, former government employee from Washington D. C.
A posse of deputies, cowboys and prospectors searched the deep canyons of the east range of Superstition mountains yesterday without success. Little hope was held last night that Ruth will be found alive.
Forty years of planning and saving were bound up in Ruth’s trip westward to seek the Lost Dutchman mine. He brought with him a variety of maps of the mountains and supposed locations of mines and declared while outfitting for his trip into the mountains that he had studied every document pertaining to the elusive mine.
Twelve days ago Ruth hired a man to drive him back into the mountains, where he pitched camp, according to C. R. Morse, Apache Junction service station proprietor, who came to Phoenix yesterday to notify sheriff’s officers of Ruth’s disappearance.
The driver, whose name Morse did not know, returned to Ruth’s camp several days ago to replenish the prospector’s supplies. Ruth was not there, nor did he return by nightfall. Search began for him the next day.
Scarcity of water in the precipitous mountains would be Ruth’s greatest handicap, searchers declared.
Ruth’s wife wired to Morse yesterday an offer of $100 reward to anyone rescuing Ruth or bringing his body out of the mountains. Ruth had been receiving his mail through Morse. Ruth is not the first prospector to disappear in the mountains in search of the famous legendary Lost Dutchman. Many have trekked into the desert and mountainous region of the purported rich mine, never to re-appear.
A soldier, it is said, first discovered the fabulously rich mine a half century ago. He appeared in valley towns at intervals laden with gold ore, but efforts to follow him back into the mountains and discover his mine always were unsuccessful. Later the soldier disappeared and with him went the secret of the locations of the mine, which prospectors later christened Lost Dutchman.